The Black Manhattan is a modern spin on the traditional Manhattan cocktail. Created by bartender Todd Smith in 2005, this cocktail replaces sweet vermouth with Amaro, an Italian herbal liqueur, resulting in a deeper and more complex flavor. The cocktail is a favorite among whiskey lovers who enjoy a richer, slightly bitter edge to their drinks.
This guide will break down the ingredients, offer tips for making the perfect Black Manhattan, and suggest food pairings that complement the cocktail’s bold profile. For more on the origins of the classic Manhattan, check out this detailed history.
The Main Components of a Black Manhattan
The Black Manhattan stands out because of its unique mix of ingredients. Let’s explore what makes it so special:
- Whiskey: This cocktail is traditionally made with rye whiskey, known for its spiciness, though bourbon can also be used for a sweeter version. If you’re looking for a recommendation, here’s a guide to the best rye whiskeys.
- Amaro: The defining feature of the BM is the use of Amaro instead of vermouth. Averna Amaro is a popular choice, offering bittersweet herbal notes. Other options like Amaro Montenegro or Cynar can also be used. Learn more about this versatile ingredient in this guide to Amaro.
- Bitters: A combination of Angostura and orange bitters helps balance the flavors, adding depth and a hint of citrus.
Crafting the Perfect Black Manhattan
Ingredients:
- 2 oz rye whiskey or bourbon
- 1 oz Amaro (such as Averna)
- 1 dash Angostura bitters
- 1 dash orange bitters
- Ice
- Garnish: Cherry or lemon twist
Instructions:
- Chill the glass: Start by chilling your glass in the freezer or by filling it with ice.
- Mix the ingredients: In a mixing glass, combine the whiskey, Amaro, and bitters. Stir with ice until well-chilled.
- Strain and serve: Strain the cocktail into the chilled glass.
- Garnish: Add a cherry or lemon twist for a final touch of flavor.
Pair your BM with a savory dish like Swordfish Nuggets to complement the cocktail’s deep flavors.
Exploring Different Versions of the Cocktail
The Black Manhattan is highly adaptable, allowing you to experiment with various ingredients. Here are a few popular variations:
- Sicilian Twist: Swap Averna for Amaro Montenegro for a lighter, more floral flavor.
- Bourbon Variation: Use bourbon instead of rye whiskey for a sweeter, smoother drink.
- Seasonal Spice: Add cinnamon or black walnut bitters for a warm, spiced version ideal for colder months.
Ideal Food Pairings
Pairing your cocktail with the right food enhances the experience. Here are some suggestions to consider:
- Appetizers: Sharp cheeses, cured meats, and roasted nuts pair beautifully with the cocktail’s bittersweet flavor.
- Main Courses: Rich meats like lamb or steak complement the boldness of the Black Manhattan.
- Desserts: Dark chocolate or tiramisu make for excellent dessert choices to accompany the cocktail.
For a unique pairing, serve your cocktail with Crab Brulee for a blend of savory and sweet.
Common Questions About the Black Manhattan
How is the Black Manhattan different from a regular Manhattan?
The Black Manhattan replaces vermouth with Amaro, giving it a more herbal and slightly bitter flavor compared to the classic Manhattan cocktail.
Can I use bourbon instead of rye whiskey?
Yes, using bourbon will create a sweeter and smoother version of the Black Manhattan.
What type of Amaro should I use?
Averna is a common choice, but you can experiment with alternatives like Amaro Montenegro or Cynar for different flavor profiles.
Should the Black Manhattan be shaken or stirred?
The Black Manhattan should be stirred, not shaken, to ensure the cocktail has the proper dilution and smooth texture.
What’s the best garnish for this cocktail?
A cherry or lemon twist works well as a garnish, adding either sweetness or a citrus note.
Final Thoughts
The Black Manhattan is a modern twist on a classic Manhattan, offering bold flavors with a hint of herbal complexity from Amaro. Whether you enjoy it with savory appetizers, hearty main dishes, or rich desserts, the cocktail provides a memorable experience for those who appreciate whiskey-based drinks. Try experimenting with different variations or pairings to find your perfect match.